Press Release: Scientists from 28 Countries Condemn
Quebec's Asbestos Exports1 



Support independent science, not industry misinformation, scientists tell Charest

Over a hundred prominent scientists in 28 countries have challenged Premier Jean Charest, who leaves on a trade mission to India on Jan. 31, to stop Quebec's export of asbestos to the developing world.

In their letter, released today, the scientists note that Quebec uses virtually none of the asbestos it mines; is spending millions of dollars to remove all forms of asbestos from its schools and buildings; and that its own health experts oppose the government's asbestos policy and have shown that in Quebec itself, it has been impossible to use any asbestos safely.

This indicates a disturbing double standard that brings dishonour on Quebec's international reputation, the scientists tell Charest.

The letter is signed by U.S. cancer expert, Dr Devra Davis, and by Sue Janse van Rensburg, Chief Executive Officer of the Cancer Association of South Africa (CANSA). "Quebec itself is experiencing an appalling epidemic of asbestos-related disease," noted Ms Rensburg, "yet it is exporting asbestos to developing countries where there are far less protections than in Quebec. This is simply indefensible."

"South Africa used to export asbestos, but has now banned it," noted Dr Davis. "If a country facing enormous economic hardships, like South Africa, can ban asbestos, then why can't Quebec?"

The scientists criticized Charest for funding industry misinformation and turning a deaf ear to his own health experts. "Independent scientists in Quebec and in India are being vilified and threatened by the asbestos industry," said Dr Davis, noting that the asbestos industry in India has notified a number of scientists that legal action will be taken against them if they do not retract their published articles concerning the threat to health posed by chrysotile asbestos. "We call on Premier Charest to categorically condemn such threats to independent science by vested interests. We ask him to give his unequivocal support to his government's own health scientists. We ask him to act honourably and end Quebec's export of this deadly product."

Dr Devra Davis
Sue Janse van Rensburg, CANSA
Magdalene Seguin, CANSA
Kathleen Ruff

January 28, 2010


1 Permission to reproduce this press release, which appeared on the RightonCanada website on January 28, 2010, has been obtained from the authors.



       Home   |    Site Info   |    Site Map   |    About   |    Top↑